Does Re-Shoring Mean a Return to Industrialized America?

I really like the article Kevin O'Marah wrote over at SCM World entitled: Re-shoring is a Red Herring.  He rightfully points out that while re-shoring is great for a variety of reasons we should not hold out hope for the whole scale re-industrialization along with the many jobs it brings.  The days of just graduating high school and going to work at the local plant are over even if manufacturing returns.

One of the reasons this is true was described in a Logistics viewpoints' prediction for 2013 where Adrian Gonzales identified "the robots keep coming". Also, back in February I wrote  a post titled: "Robots and Other Supply Chain Trends" about an interaction Kevin and I  had about the idea of robotics and how robotics is a key factor of what will allow re-shoring while not employing a lot of people.

Bottom line: Re-shoring is great for America, great for supply chains and great for the consumer (Lower cost, higher flexibility) but is not the dream people are making it appear relative to jobs and the middle class economy.

Total Business Inventory to Sales Ratios

Somehow last week got away from me, perhaps too much sun in Florida the week prior, so I did not post this on Thursday as I would have liked.  On March 13, 2013 the census bureau released the numbers showing the total business inventories to sales ratio for January.  If you remember, I posted the wholesale numbers a few days back at this post and said I was getting concerned about the inventory levels backing up in the supply chain.

This number did not fail me and as you can see by the chart above, the ratio continues to climb albeit ever so slowly.  The bottom line is either sales are going to have to pick up dramatically or the production machine is going to have to slow down.  And, of course, the latter is not good for the transportation industry as a whole. While it may be good for those in the procurement roles trying to get capacity I think everyone would say they would rather have a robust economy.

Of course this data is for January and much has happened since then.  It certainly does appear either the economy has truly started to pick up or anticipated euphoria is at least moving the stock market forward.

One item I would watch closely however is consumer credit.  While sales may be picking up in February and March (numbers next month will show us if this is a trend as I anticipate it will be) we are seeing a large growth in consumer credit again (7% growth in January as reported by the Federal Reserve).  This means the consumer, for the most part, is starting to leverage again and we all know this cannot sustain itself.  The recession caused the consumer to "de-leverage" a lot and now it appears the consumer is back to being willing to leverage themselves.

Beware the borrowing!

WebRep

currentVote

noRating

noWeight

The Week That Was - Wow!!.. But Will It Translate into Physical Goods?

Well, this was the week we have all been waiting for if you are one of those who did not abandon the market after the last downturn, stayed the course (Borrowed from Vanguard®), and rode the wave to new heights.  If you are one who did abandon the market, well, I guess this was not such a good week.

The scorecard:  Dow up 307.41 points and up 9.87% for the year. 

As always however I like to look at things through the eyes of logistics.  What does this mean for logistics (i.e., freight movement and storage) in this country?  When I look at it through that lens I see a lot of other data which continues to support the idea that the production and movement of goods is still very lackluster. Let's look at a few:

Monthly Wholesale Inventories Relative to Sales:

This number (Unlike the Total number reported on earlier) climbed 1.2% which tells us that inventory is beginning to back up at the wholesale level and will ultimately either need to be sold or production will have to slow down.  Most of this increase is in the durables number and represents an increase from a revised December number and a significant increase over January 2012.  Interesting that sales of durables are up however the inventory has grown faster than sales.

McDonald's Same Store Sales were Down:  Of course the company blames this on the lack of the extra leap day and that could be true but, I generally dismiss these types of excuses.  At the end of the day if they are that close then they are flat at best.  I use McDonalds as a barometer for world spending because it is just about everywhere and almost everyone goes there.  If you are out shopping, you probably will stop at a McDonalds sometime so it is a good measuring stick.  I know, not very scientific but these types of indicators generally work.

Personal Income and Outlays:  This was down 3.6% in January (released March 1) which again is an early indicator of not much activity in the economy which will be good.

Countering this type of news was the great news on the unemployment rate going down to 7.7%.  This is fantastic however I report it with one caution and that caution deals with the sequestration.  Most government agencies will be dealing with budget cuts via furloughs and not lay offs.  This means while the unemployment number may appear relatively unscathed during this time people's spending will decrease as they have less disposable income and are less secure.

Of course, these statistics reported in March for January are all at least 1 month old and it is theoretically possible the market is acting as a leading indicator on the physical economy rather than the financial economy.  But I doubt it.

While my meter is up and I am hoping this is the beginning of a massive boom in the physical economy I think the data says this is a financial economy activity.  Companies, while selling the same or less, are making a lot more money, have a lot of cash and the alternative investment, treasuries, barely keep up with inflation.  For these reasons I believe the market is skyrocketing and may well continue.

The question is will it translate into physical goods.  Right now the data says... Maybe.... .(OK, my meter may have moved just a bit to the right from absolutely no to .. Maybe)

WebRep

currentVote

noRating

noWeight

Macroeconomic Monday® - Data Mixed, Market Up, Consumers Feel Worse

What a combination of data!  We knew last week was going to be a "big data" week and it sure did not surprise however it certainly was mixed.  It required a view one level down to even try to make sense of what was going on.

First, the market closed over 14,000 for the first time in a long time and for those of you who mistook the economic data over the last 3 years you have really missed a hell of a ride in the stock market.  There are all sorts of reasons why this has happenned and the only thing that matters really is that it did happen and it is now at a frothy level. So, here are the highlights:

1. GDP - Shrunk by .1%: This is one which requires you to dig down a bit.  The core reason for this is the massive decrease in defense spending in anticipation of the sequester cost reductions.  Yes, government spending does matter and if this does not get resolved we will take 2% - 3% out of GDP.  This was a small glimpse.
2. Durable Goods Orders - Increased by 4.6%:  Great news showing investment by businesses which generally implies they see a good 2013 coming.  Some of this may have been due to trying to second guess any changes in depreciation rules but overall, it is a good sign.
3. Consumer Confidence - 58.6 v expectations of 64: The consumer continues to feel the blues and is just not feeling good.  We will need to watch this closely because if this translates to lower spending and the sequester cuts cause the government spending to continue to decrease at the rate it is going, the likelihood of recession will increase dramatically. I am not going so far as to blame the expiration of the payroll tax holiday as I do not think people can even calculate that for the most part.  The bottom line is while the market is growing dramatically people still feel they are one hiccup away from losing their job, losing their house and general economic problems. This causes them to feel bad and hoard cash.  This caused personal spending to miss expectations by .1%. 
4. Unemployment - 7.9%: While this ticked back up by .2% the number of jobs available has increased and a general feeling is we are rebounding in jobs.  
5. ISM Index - 53.1:  This was the big news.  Manufacturing clearly continues an increase and had a robust January.  That was really good news. Now if we can get this to improve the employment numbers we may have a real economy going here.  However, the data as one economist sees it says we could get this rebound without a big move in jobs numbers because companies have figured out how to have machines do more and more of the highly skilled work. The old argument in economics always is the trade off of capital and labor and it appears capital may be winning in "The Rise of The Robots". (note: Ignore the politics in the linked post: Just read the facts on labor v. capital)

Overall, I would say it was a great start to 2013 and the data appears like a fairly decent economy.  The risks which are very clear are:

1. Government pulls back on defense spending for real and takes with it almost the entire GDP.
2. Employment numbers truly do start decreasing and unemployment never decreases.
3. Consumer confidence never comes back. A danger to all types of recessions is you never get to "take off" speed because of hoarding and hoarding occurs when people just feel bad about the future.  

That is it for now.. Happy February!!

The Data Behind The Data on The Housing Market

A lot has been mentioned recently about the housing market and how quickly it appears to be rebounding.  It feels as if the entire country woke up in unison and decided to all go buy a house.  Feels like 2006 all over again right?

Well, not so fast.  It is important to understand where we are coming from and what the possibilities really are.  The graphs below from Northern Trust tell an interesting story:

Home sales, while increasing are still very anemic as compared to the "go-go" days of 2006.  I would never expect it to get back to that level so those who are saying, "when will housing come back" should be asking themselves, "back to what".  Further, you can see existing sales are increasing faster which generally does not have the same multiplier effect on the economy as new construction.

Behind the numbers of the existing sales also includes investors buying homes or blocks of homes to rent.  That element further reduces the multiplier effect.  And, finally, the drag on the economy of incredibly tight lending criteria means it will be a long time, if at all, that we get back to even 75% of the growth days.

Watch this closely, it is good to finally feel good, but don't get burned with unreal expectations.

Rail Volume for Week 44 Down - Hurricane Sandy

Association of American Railroads released week 44 on Thursday and as expected volumes were down significantly.  However, anyone who graphs and analyzes this data closely will need to asterisk this week forever as Hurricane Sandy drove most of it.

The data shows a 4.8% decrease in container traffic versus week 44 of 2011.  This can only be explained by the Hurricane and embargo of certain locations.  Container traffic through week 44 increased 5.6% for the year showing the increased volumes will continue and, as expected, trailer traffic on the rails continues its decline in favor of the more efficient COFC.

Overall ton miles are down both for the week and for the year and the driving factor for this is Coal.  Coal is down substantially and while petroleum products are up due to all the shale oil it is not enough, on a ton mile basis, to offset the decrease in coal.

The story continues to unfold despite the blip due to Sandy:

• COFC is up
• TOFC is down
• Overall ton miles are down
• Coal down
• Petroleum up dramatically. 

Housing - Good News Bad News for Transportation

First, I want to be clear that one month's data does not make a trend however we all have to be very pleased with the housing numbers yesterday.  According to the Wall Street Journal,

"On Wednesday, the government reported that new home-building levels surged to a four-year high last month, amid a nearly 12% rise in new building permits. "

As we all know, housing drives a lot of activity or "velocity" in the economy because along with a house comes a lot of other ancillary purchases such as appliances, furniture, drapes etc.  Housing also is a "mood" indicator because, generally speaking, people do not buy houses unless they feel fairly stable about their economic situation.  For these reasons, and I am sure a lot more, having housing move like this is a fantastic sign.  The Wall Street Journal even went so far as saying this movement may vindicate all the maligned recent activity by the Fed.

This is also good for transportation - in a way.  Transportation always gains from housing.  It is that simple and quite frankly housing is almost a singular metric for transportation companies to look at when determining the macro movement of the economy.  The last huge "boom" in trucking came when the housing market was at a froth of excitement in 2004 - 2006.

Now, for the "bad news". Housing is also right up there with manufacturing as one of the highest employment substitutes for drivers.  Drivers can migrate from construction to semi-skilled manufacturing to driving pretty easily and when construction jobs jump, drivers tend to want to move to those jobs.  Why do that and not just stay with trucking?

Two reasons help explain this migration between careers.  First, the time at home factor is big.  If a driver can even come close to replicating their driving income while staying at home they will do that.  Second, there really is no "penalty".  Most jobs and careers there is a penalty for hopping around such as loss of seniority, pay or other benefits.  For the most part (yes there are a few perks for being senior but not many and they are not highly valued relative to time at home) a driver loses nothing by pivoting to construction as they know they can move back to driving anytime they want and they will be welcomed back with a hug and a thank you.

Keep your eyes on these numbers as they develop.  If this is the beginning of a real sustained increase in construction and we get anywhere near close to 800K to 1M starts next year then the driver shortage will exacerbate really quickly.

Why Transportation Stocks Are So Important

In my last post I reported (and linked) to an article about transportation stocks and what the "warnings" mean which have been issued recently.  The graph below from the Wall Street Journal and this article really define why it is so important and why we need to follow these stocks not just because we are logisticians but because we follow the economy in general.

Graph from Wall Street Jounal

Get Ready - CSCMP 2012 in Atlanta

Those who have been in the industry a while know the Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals (CSCMP) is the premier professional organization for our industry.  From practitioners to academics, this is the organization to belong to if you want to know what is happening in our industry, networking with top individuals / thought leaders and keep an eye on the mega-trends occurring in supply chain and logistics.

This year I have the honor to co-host Track 6 - Energy and Infrastructure at the Annual Global Conference in Atlanta from September 30 to October 3. This track will have exciting discussions concerning the overall energy marketplace right to how to specifically implement Natural Gas and alternative energy strategies.  The track objectives, as stated in the program:

"Managing a sustainable supply chain is no longer just a "cool" thing to do; it is expected by the consumer and is an extension of the brand and product being sold. This track will highlight best-in-class practices and emerging technologies to reduce your carbon footprint, enhance your corporate image, and positively impact the bottom line"

I highly encourage you to put this on your appointment calendar!

Today, I will highlight the first session we will have which is from 9:45 to 11:15 on Monday, October 1, 2012 entitled: Dispelling the Myths of Energy Independence by Walter Zimmermann, Senior Technical Analyst, United ICAP.  The description of this session is:

"US energy independence is a goal that can never be achieved due to the global nature of the economy and the ability to export energy quickly to the higher priced markets. There is a lot of talk about building a stronger economy while at the same time lowering energy prices. This speaker will explain why we can’t have both, and why the financial markets are what actually drive energy price trends. He will reveal what can be done to lower energy costs, and describe how seasonal price cycles can be employed to lock in prices near their annual lows."

This will be an exciting session as it will challenge a lot of the current thoughts which exist in our industry about how we are on the beginning of a wave of cheap energy and energy independence.  Mr. Zimmermann speaks how the laws of supply and demand are not driving fuel costs but rather the "financialization" of the energy markets are really driving the costs. This session will really challenge you to think different.

Mr. Zimmermann is an exciting and dynamic speaker which will make this session very exciting.  Bring your questions!

If you would like to see him in action, take a look at this clip from CNBC:




Here is a more recent interview:

More Data on Slowing ..

As reported at the Transplace blog, Stifel Nicolaus data supports the idea of a slowing environment.

Looking at Transportation The Way We Look at China's Economy

I have read a lot recently about how you get the real GDP numbers out of China.  Don't bother with the government statistics rather just go look at the piles of coal at the electric power plants.  As China has said their economy is doing fine, observers of coal piles have seen them grow and grow.  Why is this important?  The growth of the coal piles signifies a massive slow down in the demand for electricity which, in turns, means factories are idling.  When factories idle, you have lower GDP.  Voila!  It may not be scientific however doing econometrics with raw data which is flawed is a waste of time.

So, I thought I would use this way to look at transportation and I did not like what I saw.  Driving through Chicago yesterday passing by the big intermodal yards I saw stacks and stacks of 53' containers which clearly had been "mothballed".  They were not at the yard "in transit" rather they were in the yard and parked.  They were stacked high and tight.  This indicates carriers are parking containers which clearly indicates a massive slowdown in freight pretty close to the time where it should be gearing up for the holidays.

All indications are the economy has softened dramatically and this is just another indicator.  I may patent this methodology, go to Chicago every week and take a picture, compare them against previous weeks like you would a bar graph.  My guess is this would be just as good as some of the other "analysis" I have seen.

Is The Trucking Industry Rebounding?

There is anecdotal evidence based on an informal count of trucks on the NJ turnpike showing an increase in truck traffic.   I warn you, this informal study reported on CNBC is about as informal and non scientific as you can get however when you tie it to other evidence (i.e, FEDEX financial results - profit doubles) you see some coalescing evidence that the economy is picking up and trucks are moving.

However, if you take the comments by FEDEX CFO Alan Graf at his word, evidence is the economies of the world are not growing fast enough to offset things such as high unemployment

There is a mixed bag I guess.  I chose to believe the former rather than the later.

Unemployment Claims Plummet

The singular biggest metric to watch for business activity (IMHO) is the first time unemployment claims number.  This number is going down consistently which means business activity will pick up.  Unemployed people will begin working and employed people will feel more confident.

The graph below from Northern Trust tells the story:

Since September we have been going straight down with the initial claims.  Don't let the naysayers fool you by saying "people are dropping out of the market".  These are first time claims so just about everyone files their initial claim.  Firing slows way down and therefore we know the economy is stabilizing.

Good news for everyone and especially trucking and logistics firms.  More workers, more confidence, more buying, more freight.. it is that simple.    

Q3 GDP Growth is a Fire in The Pan Spurt

Conference Board's perspective on the Q3 "growth" spurt.  Personally, I cannot imagine GDP continuing to grow when we are at 9%+ unemployment.  Just the simple economist in me coming out.

Conference Board Report

Home Construction Will Be Muted - Bad News for Logistics Providers

I think we have all learned over the last few years why home construction is always looked at by economists.  It is probably the single biggest indicator of the health of the economy.  When people buy homes all sorts of things happen:

1. Construction materials are bought
2. People are employed en masse
3. Peripherals are purchased (appliances, lights, drapes etc.)
4. Landscaping is performed...

I do not know the exact number but my guess is after someone buys a $200K house they most likely, over the next year, spend another $20K at least on "stuff".

This drives all sorts of logistics activities - warehousing and most importantly, transportation volume.  Transportation is inbound into the manufacturing plants which gear up for the activity and outbound finished goods going to all those new homes.

OK, now we know why this is so important.  This is also why it is depressing to hear home construction will be muted for a while - most likely 5 -8 years. The inventory is just too high and there are still a lot of adjustable rate mortgages to reset in 2012.  Not a good sign.

For those of you who say, "Yes, but those staying in a home will remodel" I would say this "rule" (if it ever was one) does not hold up anymore.  The reason is most people, intuitively, know they are now living in a depreciating asset and not an appreciating asset.  Remodeling makes sense in the latter as it is much like a bank account.  However, in the former remodeling is like buying a consumable product which has no sustainable value.  People know this intuitively and will not, in total, increase dramatically their major remodeling (assuming they are sane and rational).

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.